Warning: Full spoilers for the AHS: Freak Show season follow... Being that we're now four seasons deep into the American Horror Story game, I feel like it's time to look back at the triumphs and forfeits of the series. For me, the show has gotten less exciting and vibrant with each subsequent year - with Murder House being my favorite season, followed by Asylum, and then Freak Show and Coven cage-fighting it out for third place.