Rotten Tomatoes Did Not End "at The Movies"

Rotten Tomatoes Did Not End

It was announced last March that this would be the last season of "At The Movies," the iconic show started by Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel. I read a couple articles on it, and for some reason, some writers blame Rotten Tomatoes. A show with two film critics duking it out about films is somehow made irrelevant by a larger consensus on the web. It's two different mediums and two different beast. Watching two critics duking it out about a film's merits is a lot different then just looking at the box score. The former will always be more entertaining. There'll always be room for a show like Siskel & Ebert, you just have to find the right two guys. And Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert were the right two guys. They were the right opposites. They complimented each other perfectly.

When I was in high school, my favorite American actors were Sylvester Stallone, Harrison Ford, Bruce Willis, Arnold Schwarzenegger, and Kurt Russell. Yes, all action stars, except for maybe Kurt Russell. He's just there because of Big Trouble in Little China and ... ahem ... Tango and Cash. I was lifting weights and trying my best to be as manly as them. My weekly routine consisted of checking out the box office at the Sacramento Bee and watching Siskel & Ebert. I like looking at box office figures to see what people are watching - and see how my favorite actors are faring with their latest movies. The guys might be box office giants, but probably not critics' darlings.

I don't know what it is about Siskel & Ebert that hooked me the first time I saw their show on a Saturday evening. It's just two guys arguing and discussing movies. It was entertaining and informative. Just as I like to see how my actors fare at the box office, I also like to see how they fare with critics.

When I was looking for a name to call my movie review aggregation site, I was thinking "Thumbs Down" - as a tribute to the show. How cool would it be to have a big thumb squashing a bad movie. I was naive. Luckily, Ebert, Siskel, Disney and cybersquatters had already bought domain names for every permutation of "Two Thumbs Up." I had to find a more obscure name - Rotten Tomatoes - and not have to face lawsuits by the show I revered.

Since the show ended last Saturday, I thought I'll give it a final tribute by giving a brief rundown of Siskel & Ebert and its various permutations:

I started to notice that his output had lessened. His reviews were shorter. I also remember a user complaining about his shorter reviews. I sensed that something was wrong. When Gene Siskel passed away, it was still early in the development of Rotten Tomatoes. I featured him on the homepage then. It was just a large pic of him on RT's homepage for a week or so. Between him and Ebert, he's the tougher and meaner (in a good way) of the two. He'll call out producers, directors, writers, and actors when they deliver a stinker.

I actually liked this. I liked seeing and hearing what the actual critics were like. Back then, I ran the site by myself and, because of this, did all of the quote culling. I could finally attach faces to the critics and their reviews. Most of them were just way too respectful of Roger to go all out and wrestle him though. It was great for at least a season. The only problem is the ratings were inconsistent - two thumbs up from Ebert and a bunch of different critics isn't the same as just Ebert and Siskel (or Ebert and Roeper).

Richard Roeper eventually got more comfortable with his role. He might not be as knowledgeable about films as Gene Siskel, but he was energetic and had screen presence. It's like watching wise Yoda sparring with a young Jedi.

He did an admirable job holding down the fort while Ebert was out. It was interesting seeing celebrities on the show, even though most of them would only pat their peers on the back.

Still watchable. Michael Phillips and Tony Scott were kinda geeky, but they add credibility.

BEN & BEN (& RT)
I have a vested interest in this because RT was involved. Matt Atchity, the editor-in-chief of RT, was one of the regular guests on the show. He was a natural. Being interviewed on the spot is hard. I'm constantly amazed at how people can be so eloquent with these things. Ben Lyons, on the other hand, was not a natural. I felt like he had his lines memorized and was just reciting them. Much of the time, what he recited was insubstantial.

Didn't watch any of the shows until the end. Planned to, wanted to, but DVR did not cooperate. I liked them both when they were taking turns co-hosting with Richard Roeper.

Gene Siskel passed away. Roger Ebert was no longer involved with the show. The thumbs were replaced with See It, Rent It, and Skip It. The original set for the show was even destroyed to make room for Ben & Ben. Other than the format, there's nothing left from the original show. And that's the simple reason why the later shows failed.

There is hope. Roger Ebert has been developing another movie review show, and I hope it gets picked up. Meanwhile, you can always read his reviews and blog at, follow up on Twitter, and/or join his club.

  • Wait, Business Insider Does Sports Now?Wait, Business Insider Does Sports Now?
    I didn’t realize Business Insider does sports, until I saw a link to an article on Yahoo’s homepage titled “LeBron James referenced a 4-month-old Kevin Love quote in a tweet, and the fallout is getting absurd.” More
  • Broken Feeds: Is RSS Going the Way of the Dinosaurs?Broken Feeds: Is RSS Going the Way of the Dinosaurs?
    I’m been fixing a bunch of broken feeds since the new year. It started with CNN, which launched a redesign at the beginning of the year. At the time, all of their RSS feeds were broken as a result of that (more about this later). More
  • Finally Upgraded Sites to Use New Hardware from Linode Cloud: SSDs, Double RAM, Faster CPUsFinally Upgraded Sites to Use New Hardware from Linode Cloud: SSDs, Double RAM, Faster CPUs
    Around April, my VPS provider Linode announced that they’ve just finished a major $45M upgrade to their hardware and network, which means free upgrades for their existing users. The new hardware uses SSD RAID drives and faster CPUs. I hadn’t bothered because Wopular and Movies With Butter have been relatively stable. More
  • The Identical Look of Firefox and Chrome Caused Site ShutdownThe Identical Look of Firefox and Chrome Caused Site Shutdown
    In my previous article, I mention how the latest version of Firefox has a nearly identical look to Google’s Chrome web browser. When I’m working on new features for my sites, I use Firefox for testing and Chrome to see what the results look like to the users. I knew one of these days, because both browsers look the same now, I would confuse one for the other and put up untested programming code that would cause havoc on my sites. More
  • Firefox 29: Looks Just Like Chrome NowFirefox 29: Looks Just Like Chrome Now
    I just upgraded to Firefox 29, the latest version. Well, it’s more like it upgraded itself. Although I like the newer cleaner look, it’s harder and harder to tell the difference between it and Chrome, except the latter is still seemingly snappier. Firefox 29 has buttons at the top left for both bookmarking and access to the bookmark list. More
  • The Only People Willing to Pay for Twitter Are Users with over 100K Followers
    So far, I’ve only heard of two people who are willing to pay for Twitter - Guy kawasaki and Roger Ebert. If you search on Google, you’ll probably find more, but those are the only two I’ve read about. They have one thing in common - they each have over 100,000 followers. More
  • It's Not Good to be Neutral: CNNIt's Not Good to be Neutral: CNN
    I guess you just can’t be in the middle when you’re covering news: “CNN, founded in 1980 and now owned by Time Warner Inc, has tried to hold the middle ground in its news coverage, a position that some blame for its ratings erosion, while ratings have risen for competitors Fox News and MSNBC, which blend news with opinion and political commentary.” More
  • TV Ratings: Oscars Posterized NBA All-StarsTV Ratings: Oscars Posterized NBA All-Stars
    Because of the shorten NBA season caused by the lockout, this is the first time the telecast of the NBA All-Star game went head-to-head with the 84th Academy Awards. I thought the basketball game would get crushed, even with Linsanity in attendance - technically, he was only in the Rising Stars Challenge which took place on Friday. Who’s bright idea was it to go head-to-head with one of the biggest tv events of the year? More
  • I Reviewed Donnie Yen's Latest "Wu Xia" on MoviesWithButter
    I just got Donnie Yen's latest in the mail about a week ago, so I reviewed it on MWB: "Peter Chan’s “Wu Xia” is Donnie Yen’s best film since “Ip Man.” It might not be the fight-fest that fans expect from Yen, but it’s a visually striking film that engrosses with its unique take on the martial arts genre and entertains with Yen’s wuxia-style choreography." I'm a Donnie Yen fan, so I may be a bit biased. More
  • Ad Revenue Trends for the Four Seasons
    Working at Rotten Tomatoes kinda messed up my general view of advertising trends. The movie season peaks during Summer, takes a nosedive during Fall, heads back up during the Winter arounds Oscars, and levels off again during Spring. It’s a bit different from what I’ve experienced so far with Wopular, which is probably more in tune with the average website. More


Comment On This Story

Welcome to Wopular!

Welcome to Wopular

Wopular is an online newspaper rack, giving you a summary view of the top headlines from the top news sites.

Senh Duong (Founder)
Wopular, MWB, RottenTomatoes

Subscribe to Wopular's RSS Fan Wopular on Facebook Follow Wopular on Twitter Follow Wopular on Google Plus

MoviesWithButter : Our Sister Site

More News