Mouton Rothschild 1989. Photo by Martin Lengemann/ullstein bild via Getty Images A mix-up led to two tables getting each other's wine order at Balthazar in New York City. Four Wall Street businessmen received an $18 bottle, while a young couple received a bottle that actually cost $2,000. The owner said that the businessmen didn't notice the difference and even praised the cheaper wine. Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories. A mix-up at New York City restaurant Balthazar led to a young couple getting the deal of a lifetime as they were accidentally served a $2,000 bottle of Mouton Rothschild 1989 after ordering an $18 Pinot, Decanter reported.A server inadvertently poured both wines into identical decanters, restaurant owner Keith McNally explained on Instagram.