Emmy voters seemed to be as divided over Game of Thrones‘ final season as the rest of the fantasy series’ fans. On the heels of a controversial ending, Thrones took home the prize it most needed to win to cement its place in television history: Best Drama. But, one week after the series picked up 10 Creative Arts Emmys, it only won one other major award at the 71st Primetime Emmy Awards — Best Supporting Actor in a Drama for Peter Dinklage — and the night never quite evolved into the victory lap that many fans were expecting. It’s a fitting end to a complicated season.