Feeling duped and disappointed, a New Gloucester man says the signed Patriots helmet he won in a charity raffle has since turned out to be a fake. James MacNaught is a big Patriots fan, with a living room to prove it. Entire shelves are filled with memorabilia, but his most cherished possession lives under a glass case, in a hidden location. [Subscribe to our free morning newsletter and get the latest headlines in your inbox] “Team helmet signed by 45 of the players,” he said. MacNaught said he won it in a raffle hosted by the Optimist Clubs of New England back in 2002. “They drove up.